Concord Township Fire Levy…Proponents for the levy

[LFC Comments:  We received this article from Mr. Andy Rose, Concord Administrator.  Since we always honor a commitment, we are providing a forum for those that support the levy.  We believe in vigorous debates, and then let the voters decide whether to pass the levy or not.  Look for several articles from citizens opposing the levy.] 

*****

Concord Township Trustees held a special meeting on August 4th, to further review the financing options for the Fire Station Project that were presented and discussed in the previous Stakeholder meetings. The Trustees gained much insight from the stakeholder meetings and have used that input to help revise and also continue to move this critical project forward in a fiscally responsible way.

Over the past several months, our Board of Trustees and Fire Chief have worked very hard to garner input from the community through several hours of stakeholder meetings, field phone calls and emails from residents, meet with architects and revise designs.  They have acted as good stewards to ensure the least amount of financial burden for our residents. Throughout this process, community members and Trustees have all agreed that we desperately need new fire stations for the health of our first responders and to protect them and maintain their safety so they can continue to serve and protect our community.

At the August 4th special meeting, financing options were reviewed, discussed and evaluated. The projection for the cost of the total project is $12 million. The Trustees voted unanimously to pursue an $8 million bond levy. This would allow the township to use the bond levy to pay for the majority of the project. The remaining funds needed for the project will come from existing revenue sources. The bond levy is asking for a portion of the total, not the entire project cost.  The levy will be on the ballot in November as Issue #1 to be voted on by Concord Township voters.

Our Fire Station Project is critical for our community and our first responders.  “We hope our community comes together on the financing to support our firefighters and first responders and to improve Concord Township,” said Carl Dondorfer, Trustee.

We would like to share with you some of the frequently asked questions we have received over the course of our stakeholder meetings and throughout the project.  Please use our contacts at the bottom of the email to reach out with any additional questions.

Issue 1 image

What does the $8 m bond levy mean?

The bond levy will be placed on the ballot in the November 2020 election as Issue 1, to be voted on by Concord Township residents.  It will be .6mills which calculates to about $21/year for a $100,000 taxable property value.

Does this mean that the Station will cost $8 Million?  

No. In fact, we do not know what the cost of the stations will be yet.  We currently estimate the total of both stations to be approximately $12 million. It will be some time before we see actual costs of construction for both stations. Once the conceptual drawings are approved and finalized, the engineer, AECOM (in Cleveland) will proceed with design development. After financing is secured and a notice to proceed is issued, the engineers and architects assemble the construction documents. (The most recent conceptual drawings are available here.)

After these documents are completed, which could take several months, and the building permit is secured, the project is put out to bid through a Request for Proposal (RFP).  The contractors review the design documents and assemble subcontractors and determine the amount they will charge to build the station. When the Township receives all of the quotes from the contractors, they review and select the lowest and best bid.  At this point, we will have a formal cost estimate with building materials, labor costs (since we are a government entity, we use prevailing wage contract) and timeline.  So, the total projection of $12 Million is a budget or estimate of what we think it might cost in total for both stations at this point in the process.

Why do we need new fire stations now?

Now is the best time to move forward with building new fire stations for our community for several reasons. Protecting our firefighters is critical, especially when there is a pandemic, so the community has safe and healthy first responders who are ready to serve and protect. This is a much needed investment in our community’s safety.  Additionally, the timing will allow the township to save money,” said Amy Lucci, Trustee.

The projected life of the existing facilities was estimated to be 50 years when they were built in the 1960’s. Our 50+ year old stations are not up to standards nor are they adequately sized or capable of housing all of the emergency equipment and vehicles necessary for today’s emergency responses. Further, the buildings do not have any place for decontamination for our first responders. The Concord Fire Department has only one zone—a “Hot Zone” with no decontamination area and no storage for Personal Protective Equipment (PPE.)  Fire departments are now designed to have three zones to allow for safe decontamination of deadly carcinogens which allow for removal from personnel after a fire or when responding to calls which expose responders to blood, chemicals, radiation or biological toxins.

Additionally, building in this economic climate is ideal.  With very low interest rates and construction costs stabilized, we can secure rates and bids that allow us to get more for our money.  “The current drop in interest rates and a slowing of the commercial construction market offer the township an opportunity to further reduce the cost at a time when over half the township will not see an increase to their taxes with the expiration of the Morley library levy,” said Amy Dawson, Fiscal Officer.

Additionally, since 2020 is a Presidential election year, there are no Board of Election costs to place the levy on the ballot which will save us $24,000.

If we were to delay this project any longer, it could likely become more of a financial burden on our residents along with an even more serious health and safety issue for our first responders. Our Board of Trustees collectively agrees that due diligence has been done to prove the project’s worthiness to move forward responsibly. 

What has changed since the November 2019 Election proposal?

The Fire Project Levy in November of 2019 was a $10 million bond levy for constructing, furnishing, and equipping new fire stations with designs that were presented by the previous board of Trustees.  After researching and conducting community stakeholder meetings, the new Board of Trustees has reduced the total amount of the levy by 20%.  Station #1 went through a significant redesign with the sitting Board of Trustees in collaboration with community input. The millage for the new levy is .6mills which is 28% less due to historically low interest rates and will allow for the construction of two stations.  (.6mills calculates to about $21/year for a $100,000 taxable property value)

How does Concord Township compare in terms of taxes? 

We are fortunate in Concord Township to be the lowest township in terms of taxes in all of Lake County.  We are in the lower 1/3 of the county in terms of taxes. There are three zip codes in Concord; Riverside is the 9th lowest; Mentor is the 10th lowest and Chardon is the 13th lowest.   Only 17% of your taxes go to Concord Township.

How does the Morley Library Construction Levy affect taxes for the Painesville side of Concord?

60% of Concord residents live in the portion of the township that pays taxes on the Morley Library Construction Levy. You may notice your taxes distributed to Morley was a little less in 2020.  The remaining millage (.6mills) will be taken away on your 2021 bill.  Basically, this levy and the Fire Station Levy are going to be about the same.  So, this levy will expire before the Fire levy would begin. The $8 million bond levy for the fire station will be .6mills.  So, residents in this area of the township will see no increase in their taxes at all with this levy. 

“The bottom line is that our firefighters need our support.  Everyone who lives, works and visits our beautiful community, depends on our fire department.  We have asked our firefighters for too long to make do with these inadequate, 50 year old facilities, which compromise their health and safety.  We now need to ask Concord residents for their support,” said Morgan McIntosh, Trustee.

Please click below to take a virtual tour of our fire stations:

 

 

Please contact us with any questions:

Please feel free to contact Fire Chief Sabo at 440-354-7503 or firechief@concordtwp.com, Township Administrator Andy Rose at (440) 354-7513 or arose@concordtwp.com or our trustees at the following:

Morgan McIntosh mcintosh@concordtwp.com

Carl Dondorfer cdondorfer@concordtwp.com

Amy Lucci alucci@concordtwp.com



Categories: Concord, Lake County Cities & Townships, Uncategorized

Tags: ,

9 replies

  1. The funny part is that $21/$100,000 of valuation equates to a .21 mil rate not a .6 mill rate.

    (.21 * 100,000) / 1,000 = 21

    (.6 * 100,000) / 1,000 = 60

    or roughly 3x what has been quoted here.

    Like

    • Their calculation is correct. This can be confusing, but let us try to explain. You are forgetting to calculate the assessed value.

      The easiest calculation is $35.00 x .6 mil = $21.00 per $100,000 home valuation.

      The more complicated tax calculation: $100,000 market valuation x 35% = $35,000 assessed value
      $35,000 x .6 mills = $21,000 / 1,000 = $21.00 per $100,000 of market valuation

      Hope this helps…

      Like

  2. It sure does! I’m thankful for being safe.

    Like

  3. I am in full agreement with the need for new fire stations in Concord Twp. I’m very concerned with the financial options and with the chosen 8 million Levy. I attended the second and third stakeholder meetings to gain insight and relate my opinion on the project. One of the most frequently asked questions regarded the option to build station 2 now with existing resources on hand vice raising taxes. Why was this not part of the FAQ’s the Township chose to address in their news release?

    Like

  4. I asked the same question. Back in February, Amy Dawson, the fiscal officer, said she had $6 million she could put towards the fire station project. Four months later at the first stakeholder meeting in June, a slide was presented with a $12 million price tag for building two stations.

    At the Trustee meeting at the end of July, a $6 million levy cost was voted as an option to explore with the auditor. This amount coupled with the $6 million from the township would have represented a 50% – 50% split with the taxpayers.

    When the Trustees voted to place an $8 million levy on the November 2020 ballot, taxpayers are now expected to pay 70% of the tab, while the township contributes only 30%. I do not see a good deal especially for people who are struggling to pay their high property taxes now.

    With the Morley Library debt service levy coming off our taxes after 20 years of paying for the construction of it, I was looking for a reduction of my property taxes, not an increase. I did not need a levy for 26 years that will spend my tax savings likely past my lifetime.

    I concur with Mr. McCullough in the prudent step of first building the much needed fire station 2 on Prouty Road with the money the Township has on hand coupled with a short term low interest rate loan that could be paid off in two years with the $750,000 in yearly JEDD revenue.

    The Township could have proven to taxpayers they could complete the project economically during this pandemic and financial crisis. This was a missed opportunity for which residents will have to vote their pocketbook, and the firefighters lose more time.

    Like

  5. 26 years is a long time to pay taxes. Why can’t the Trustees live within the budget. Getting over $800,000 (was $750,000 last year) a year in unencumbered funds should be enough of a buffer so as NOT to raise our taxes again. Why not sell the 7 acres for over $2,000,000 to offset any expenditures.
    As a side note, why is there a $15,000 bonus for the JEDD consultant to find a developer to put high density housing in that area….why….why….why????

    Like

  6. The Township does not have $6 million on hand for Station 2 We have $2 million set aside for station 2. The remainder of funds on hand are for operational expenses for the entire Township. Mrs. Dawson made that clear at the Trustee meeting on August 5, 2020 (See video at the 1:30-2:05 mark) https://concordtwp.com/government/public-meetings/

    To build Station 2 first, as suggested in “Anonymous’s” comment above, would require the Township to wait approximately 2 years. Taking on short-term debt for this to speed up the process would further delay Station 1 that would likely result in higher construction costs coupled with a higher interest rate.

    The option outlined in the comments by “Anonymous” is not practical. Utilizing the $2 million on hand would require a short-term loan of approximately $2 – $2.5 million. Even with low interest, the JEDD dollars would not allow this to be paid off in two years. The math simply does not work. The plan to pay cash for station 2 was always predicated on building Station 1 first, while we continue to save for Station 2.

    The Trustees clearly articulated that asking for the .6 mil levy would place the Township in better financial shape. The difference between the two levy options was .15 mils, which equates to $5.25 a year per $100K and allows the Township the ability to pay down debt at a much faster pace. I think the health and safety of all of our firefighters is worth an additional $5.25 a year.

    Like

  7. Andy, when Concord residents need to replace something, they scale back any extravagance until they can afford it. They don’t go around borrowing from family and friends.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: